Public alarm over TDSB leadership; what is happening in our school systems?

Editor’s Note: We’re spotlighting this December article again because its insights continue to resonate.

There has been widespread concern and strong public reaction following the provincial government’s dismissal of Toronto District School Board (TDSB) Director of Education Clayton La Touche, only six months into his tenure. Education unions and multiple stakeholders have expressed alarm, characterizing the move as an intervention in the democratic governance of public education.

One visible response is a petition launched by KA on Change.org titled “Reverse the Unjust Dismissal of TDSB Director of Education Clayton La Touche.” The petition outlines what it describes as key facts and contextual information intended to support the claim that the dismissal was unfair and unwarranted.

The petition opens with a forceful statement, “The abrupt and unfair dismissal of TDSB Director of Education Clayton La Touche by the Ontario government is a significant infringement on democratic rights and an evident abuse of power.”

It further argues that the decision has destabilized Ontario’s education system and raised broader concerns about the integrity of democratic processes governing educational institutions.

Numerous individuals have posted personal messages in response. Charlotte of Aurora wrote, “Another political hot potato for Education Minister Casandra and the Ford government. Who are these supervisors such as Gupta, former advisor to Metrolinx, including projects such as the Eglinton Crosstown LRT, and also involved with mergers and acquisition? Do they have any experience, or qualifications whatsoever in education?”

The petition concludes with a call to action, stating, “Reversing this decision is not only imperative for restoring stability within the TDSB, but also crucial for setting a precedent that democratic principles and justice are upheld in our society.”

It urges community members, educators, parents, and students to demand transparency, accountability, and reinstatement of the director.

Additional commenters echoed similar concerns. Joan of Brampton wrote, “The recent dismissal of Clayton La Touche highlights how justice appears to be just a word when we consider the treatment of certain individuals within the TDSB, the province, and Canada as a whole.”

Lucy, also from Brampton, emphasized process issues, “A transparent process is needed. Over the past five years, at least four directors have been terminated. Now we are bringing in managers, not educators, to lead school boards.”

Others focused on La Touche’s character. Saundra wrote, “I have known this man personally for over 40 years. His integrity, loyalty, and love for people, community, children, and family is superior.”

Gloria stated, “I am very disturbed by the unjust dismissal of a qualified, intelligent TDSB educator.”

Some comments raised broader social concerns. Eitel wrote, “Why is it that every time a Black man steps up, he is brought down?”

Robert questioned the timing and fairness of the decision, “How can it be fair, or just, to terminate this man after a few months? This is egregious in its injustice.”

Another commenter warned, “This thinly veiled attack on public education and the deliberate destabilization of school boards will only serve to hurt students.”

Those interested in reviewing or signing the petition can find it on Change.org.