BY SIMONE J. SMITH
“It has been said that Jews are the canary in the mine. Hatred against them will eventually be transferred to other minorities. Your responsibility to the Caribbean people demands that you stand for fairness and equality for all minorities.”
“I am appalled at your anti-Semitic article that appeared in your paper. Please issue an immediate apology. I trust this odious article was due to your ignorance, not any anti-Semitism on your part.”
“Ya Mon,
Why would you print a nasty anti-Semitic article by this person, Steven Kaszab.
He gets all his facts wrong!”
One by one, the emails rolled in. The three of us, Grant Browning, Trish Browning, and myself sat together and read each and every emotionally driven email. We heard and felt the anger through the email, and we accepted that somehow, an article that had appeared in our publication had offended members of a community.
As a team, we asked ourselves some questions; was there more about this topic that we needed to know? Yes! Did the representing community know something that we didn’t? Absolutely.
What we do know is that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict dates back to the end of the nineteenth century. In 1947, the United Nations adopted Resolution 181 (https://www.un.org/unispal/document/auto-insert-208958/) known as the Partition Plan, which sought to divide the British Mandate of Palestine into Arab and Jewish states.
It was on May 14th, 1948, the State of Israel was created, sparking the first Arab-Israeli War. The war ended in 1949 with Israel’s victory, but 750,000 Palestinians were displaced, and the territory was divided into three parts: the State of Israel, the West Bank (of the Jordan River), and the Gaza Strip.
Over the following years, tensions rose in the region, particularly between Israel and Egypt, Jordan, and Syria. (https://www.cfr.org/global-conflict-tracker/conflict/israeli-palestinian-conflict) Tensions remain between these two groups, and there has been worry that renewed tensions will escalate into large-scale violence. According to the Global Conflict Tracker, the United States has an interest in protecting the security of its long-term ally Israel and achieving a lasting deal between Israel and the Palestinian territories, which would improve regional security.
I say all of that to say this; I understand why Mike Fegelman, the Executive Director of Honest Reporting Canada, approached us. In his words, he feels that we have “Published an anti-Semitic conspiracy theory that has the potential to fan the flames of hatred against Canada’s Jewish community.”
The article that he is referring to is one written by our Journalist Steven Kaszab, a person who I know is the furthest thing from anything anti. He joined our paper as a concerned citizen, and his volume of work has been nothing less than encouraging, engaging, and empowering to all readers of our paper. There is a line in his article “Israel, a nation that applies a system of oppression, manipulation and racial prejudice towards the Palestinians,” that can be found at (https://torontocaribbean.com/israel-a-nation-that-applies-a-system-of-oppression-manipulation-and-racial-prejudice-towards-the-palestinians/) that states, ““Canadian, American and British politicians continue to kowtow to their populations Jewish Lobbyists,” was mentioned in several of the emails. This is the line that really seems to have sparked the anger that is currently being felt by some members of the Jewish community.
What this had me realize is that the tension that was mentioned earlier between the Jewish community and Palestinians is real, and alive as ever, and as watchdogs for their people, it is in their right to speak out against anyone who comes at their community, and they do this with a unity that is commendable.
On Monday, January 31st, 2022, another article was published by Honest Reporting Canada, written by Robert Walker. In this article “Toronto Caribbean Newspaper Publishes Column Whitewashing Hamas Terrorism,” Robert states, “Honest Reporting Canada and its subscribers sent scores of complaints to the publication and its editors, but Toronto Caribbean has yet to respond to complaints, nor take any corrective action.
A deeper look into Toronto Caribbean finds that its proclivity to publish anti-Israel misinformation is not new. In a column published on June 9th, 2021 on TorontoCaribbean.com, Omniya Ali used the Israeli-Palestinian conflict to peddle some of the most egregious and baseless, but nevertheless widely attempted slurs against Israel.”
Once again, I must speak in defense of our past writer Omniya Ali. Her volume of articles written against human rights issues found around the world. She has never slandered or slurred, and it is unfortunate that members of the organization see her work in that light. Really, it is a shame. To say that we have a proclivity meaning; a natural propensity or inclination; a predisposition, to publish anti-Israel misinformation is erroneous, and I am unsure as to why such an assertion has been made. Two articles out of 1000’s of articles do not show proclivity to anything, but I digress.
Honest Reporting Canada is an independent grassroots organization promoting fairness and accuracy in Canadian media coverage of Israel and the Middle East. What they do is monitor the media, recognize excellence and expose inaccuracy and bias in Canadian reporting in the region. Several news outlets have described them as a “Pro-Israel media watchdog group.”
They have called out any publication that they feel reports news that speaks against the Jewish community in any way, and I have provided some examples below:
Exposed: The Dark Anti-Israel Side of Desmond Tutu The Media Never Reported
By Robert Walker January 27th, 2022
“While the media is justified in recognizing the positive aspects of Tutu’s work, his anti-Israel agenda severely tarnished his legacy, and as uncomfortable as it may be, the media should not shy away from telling the full story of Desmond Tutu.”
CBC Spreads Misinformation About Eviction of Palestinian Family In Sheikh Jarrah
By Mike Fegelman January 20th, 2022
“On the evening of January 19th, CBC Radio reported on the eviction of the Salihiyas, a Palestinian family from Sheikh Jarrah (Shimon Hatzadik in Hebrew) in east Jerusalem, but instead of providing adequate context about this controversial issue, CBC gave a platform to unfounded claims that Israel was trying to expropriate the land to give to Jewish residents.”
Time Magazine Gives Cover to Anti-Israel Propaganda Photo In Its Top 100 Photos of 2021 Issue
By Robert Walker January 3rd, 2022
“In a year of so many important news stories, it was shameful that Time Magazine, a publication with a large Canadian and U.S. readership, chose to single Israel out for exclusive censure and condemnation.”
SIGN OUR PETITION! Toronto Star Gives Hamas A Free Pass In Reporting On Gaza Environmental Crisis
By Robert Walker December 28th, 2021
Canada’s Media Should Hold NDP To Account For Toxic Anti-Israel Resolutions
By Robert Walker April 14th, 2021
I appreciate and commend Honest Reporting for what they do for their community. It lies very similarly to the goals and mission of the Toronto Caribbean Newspaper. They show unity is such a powerful way, and I wish in many ways that we as a community were able to do this with such tenacity.
During this time of division, it is sad to know that the words of our writers have been taken the way they have. What would have been appreciated is that instead of blasting us on your website and Social Medias, and throwing words like anti-Semitic at us, is to professionally contact us and discuss with us the issues that you had with the original article. We could have shared perspectives, and desires for change together, found common ground between us, or even better, new ground.
We can admit, there are aspects of this conflict that no one knows except the two groups involved, and we could have worked together to highlight the discrepancies that you felt were in the article and find a way to harmonize instead of using threats, and name-calling.
As news outlets from communities that have been disenfranchised for years, we must find better ways to deal with conflict that does arise. People are not always going to say the right things, and we may never line up the same way, but there are ways that we can gain a deeper understanding of our alternate points of view.
What this did teach us, as a publication, is to be mindful of opinions that our writers do make in their articles. EVERYTHING that is written must be backed up with proof, so that if there is a need to defend a position, we can do so intelligently, and with confidence.
Thank you, Honest Reporting and the Jewish community, for shedding light on the many sides of the conflict between Israel and Palestine. With this knowledge, we can report in a more balanced way, especially when it comes to sensitive topics such as this one. Learning is growing, and when you know better, you do better!
Rabbi David Mivasair
January 31, 2022 at 6:21 pm
Please do not cave in to pressure from the Zionist thought police here in Canada. And please don’t refer to your critics as “the Jewish community”. They represent one narrow band in the very wide spectrum of opinion among us Jews in Canada. They pose as “the Jewish community” and attempt to silence anyone who promotes views critical of Israel, including silencing their fellow Jews. Many of us know from first hand experience that Israel’s brutal abuse of Palestinians must be exposed and opposed.
Dr Robert Yufe
January 31, 2022 at 7:34 pm
I was born in Trinidad and Tobago and I am Jewish. The articles published in your newspaper are factually incorrect. If you would spend the time studying this complicated issue, you would have realized that. You have an obligation to correct falsehoods. A direct attack against the only Jewish state in the world and the only democratic state in the Middle East while ignoring other well known human rights violations in the rest of the world can only be interpreted as an anti-semitism. You should familiarize yourself with what most Western countries in the world have adopted and known as the international definition of anti-Semitism.
Sherry Abdul
February 1, 2022 at 12:15 pm
They aren’t attacking you. Lawd you are blowing this out of proportion. Publications make errors, thats normal. You contact them, politely help them. You are pure drama boi
Mrs Graham
February 2, 2022 at 5:16 pm
Well said.
David Garber
January 31, 2022 at 6:36 pm
That organization does not represent the Jewish Community. I’m sorry you had to endure this.
Paul Oziel
January 31, 2022 at 7:40 pm
I’m of Jewish decent, and proud. I’m so disappointed to see this type of organization that claims to represent our views and culture take pride in attacking other organizations. Reading that they did not contact you first to try and come to a peaceful resolution before publicly attacking you is very dishonourable.
MIRIAM T
January 31, 2022 at 8:53 pm
I CALL ON HONEST REPORTING TO ISSUE A FULL RETRACTION AND APOLOGY TO THIS PUBLICATION. IF YOU DID NOT CONTACT THEM BEFORE BRINGING THIS PUBLIC, YOU HAVE ZERO MERIT. YOU CLAIM TO REPRESENT OUR COMMUNITY, A WATCHDOG ORGANIZATION IS SUPPOSED TO LOOK OUT FOR OUR COMMUNITY AND KEEP PEACE, NOT INSTIL ANGER. YOU SHOULD NEVER HAVE ATTACKED THIS COMMUNITY WITHOUT TRYING TO COME TO A PEACEFUL RESOLUTION.
YOU DO NOT REPRESENT OUR COMMUNITY HONEST REPORTING, YOU ARE A HIT JOB FOCUSED ON CREATING DIVISION AND ANGER.
Sherry Abdul
February 1, 2022 at 12:12 am
These guys want to point fingers?
Read some of their content on their site, nothing but hate, anger and division and these guys are watchdogs? They probably cause more problems than they fix!
Jennifer Stewart
February 1, 2022 at 1:20 am
Wow! These guys use serious bully tactics! So unprofessional
Eric
February 1, 2022 at 4:54 am
“Honest Reporting Canada” is a misnomer. The organization
is an extremely one-sided defender of Israel’s war crimes.
Nonetheless, this line rings false and falls into the trap (as HRV does
in a differenct way) of lumping all Jews together as having one view:
“Canadian, American and British politicians continue to kowtow
to their populations Jewish Lobbyists”
In facct, many, if not most Zionists in North America are not Jewish.
Many are right-wing evangelicals or just political opportunists.
For a progressive perspective by a growing number of Canadian Jews,
see https://www.ijvcanada.org/
Jake Sherman
February 1, 2022 at 11:59 am
They’re attacks look targeted probably funded by George Soros.
Benjamin Cuss
February 1, 2022 at 1:43 pm
The description in the “Executive Directors” bio kills me: “Mike’s focus is on delivering efficiency and professionalism” – I’m just wondering where the professionalism part is in attacking organizations without first coming to some sort of resolution?
I sent this to a few of my Jewish friends and they quickly pointed out that the organization is anti-Isreal
Two of them were lawyers and mentioned that you guys actually have grounds for defamation and a bunch of other fancy legal words, especially being the case that they did not contact you first before they attacked you publicly – might be something to look in to.
Keep doing your thing guys
Benjamin Cuss
February 1, 2022 at 1:47 pm
Sorry, I meant
The description in the “Executive Directors” bio kills me: “Mike’s focus is on delivering efficiency and professionalism” – I’m just wondering where the professionalism part is in attacking organizations without first attempting to come to some sort of resolution?
Robert Yufe
February 2, 2022 at 10:22 am
Did Toronto Caribbean newspaper contact anyone in the israeli government before writing their factually incorrect oped?
You are giving the Toronto Caribbean Newspaper very bad advice to start a defamation lawsuit that would result in a loss and then having to pay legal fees to Honest Reporting.
I suspect that the editors of the Toronto Caribbean newspaper as smarter than you give them credit for.
Any verbal advice given by a lawyer for free is not worth anything.